Decoding Hadiths on Consumption of Red Meat in Islam

 

There has been a debate regarding the authenticity of certain Hadiths that advise against the consumption of cow meat. Some argue that these narrations appear to contradict the Qur’anic permission to consume the meat of cattle. Without delving into the authenticity of these narrations—on which scholars have expressed differing views—I will focus instead on interpreting their meaning, assuming for discussion’s sake that they are authentic

The Hadiths in Question:

  1. ” أخبرنا عبد الله بن فضالة نا محمد بن يوسف عن سفيان يعني الثوري عن قيس بن مسلم عن طارق بن شهاب عن عبد الله بن مسعود قال: قال رسول الله صلي الله عليه وسلم: ما أنزل الله داءً إلا أنزل له دواء، فعليكم بألبان البقر، فإنها ترم من الشجر كله”. (سنن الکبریٰ  ٤/ ١٩٣، رقم الحديث: ٦٨٦٣))

“The Messenger (s.a.w.) of Allah  said: ‘For every disease that Allah has sent down, He has also sent down a cure for it. So drink the milk of cattle/bovine (Al-Baqaru البقرُ), for they graze on every kind of tree.” [Al-Baihaqi in Sunan al-Kubra (4/193, Hadith No. 6863)]

  • أَلْبَانُهَا شِفَاءٌ، وَسَمْنُهَا دَوَاءٌ، وَلَحْمُهَا دَاءٌ [مسند ابن الجعد : 2683]

“Its milk is healing, its butter is a medicine (medicine is taken in small quantities), and its meat is a disease.” [Musnad Ibn al-Ja’d (Hadith No. 2683)]

  •    عَلَيْكُمْ بأَلْبَانِ الْبَقَرِ وَسُمْنَانِهَا، وَإِيَّاكُمْ وَلُحُومَهَا؛ فَإِنَّ أَلْبَانَهَا وَسُمْنَانَهَا دَوَاءٌ وَشِفَاءٌ، وَلُحُومَهَا دَاءٌ   [مستدرك الحاكم : 8475]     

“Take the milk and butter of Cattle/Bovine (Al-Baqaru البقرُ) and avoid their meat, for their milk and butter are healing, but their meat is a disease.”  [Mustadrak al-Hakim (Hadith No. 8475)]

Authenticity of the Narrations:

 Most hadith scholars have classified these narrations as weak (dha‘if) in terms of their chains of transmission. Among those who have critiqued their authenticity are:

  • Imam al-Zarkashi  [al-Tadhkirah fi al-Ahadith al-Mushtahira (p. 148)]
  • Hafiz Ibn Hajar  [al-Imta‘ fi al-Arba‘in al-Mutasa’il al-Sama‘ (p. 100)]
  • Imam al-Sakhawi  [al-Maqasid al-Hasanah (p. 722, 863)]

However, some hadith scholars, including Shaykh al-Albani, have deemed these hadiths to be authentic (Sahih).

References include:

  • Silsilat al-Ahadith al-Sahihah by Albani (Hadith Nos. 1533, 1943)
  • Silsilat al-Huda wa al-Nur by Albani (Sharh al-Shari‘ah: p. 236)
  • Al-Manhaj fi Majal al-Iman by Halimi (2/31)

If these narrations are accepted as authentic, they do not imply that cow meat is haram (unlawful); rather, they suggest moderation in the consumption of red meat, possibly due to health considerations. The Prophet’s guidance in this context could be interpreted as cautioning against excessive intake of Red Meat for health reasons—not issuing a religious prohibition.

Allama Syed Abdullah Tariq

 

Interpretation and Context:

In Arabic, the word al-Baqaratu (اَلبقرَۃُ) specifically refers to the cow, while al-Baqaru (اَلبقرُ) includes bovine animals, including buffaloes. Notably, buffaloes are not native to Saudi Arabia. Thus, it is likely that al-Baqaru in these narrations referred generally to avoid the flesh of bovine animals and, by extension, red meat, rather than cow meat exclusively.

If these narrations are accepted as authentic, they do not imply that cow meat is haram (unlawful); rather, they suggest moderation in consumption of Red Meat, possibly due to health considerations. The Prophet’s guidance in this context could be interpreted as cautioning against excessive intake of Red Meat for health reasons, not issuing a religious prohibition.

Regarding Qur’anic Verses:

 The command of the cow slaughter mentioned in Surah al-Baqarah (2:67–71) pertains to a specific cow that had become an object of reverence among Bani Israel. It was not a general endorsement of cow meat but a specific directive in a particular context. Therefore, these Ayahs do not conflict with the hadiths in question.

Moreover, the Qur’an permits the consumption of meat from al-An‘ām (الأنعام), generally translated as “livestock,” in verse 16:5 and elsewhere. While most translators render this as “cattle,” (bovine) the term actually includes a broader category of domesticated grazing animals (e.g., camels, sheep, goats, cows and buffaloes). These hadiths do not revoke or contradict this general Qur’anic permission.

Conclusion:

 If the hadiths advising moderation in consuming bovine meat (red meat of cattle) are authentic, they should be understood in the light of medical advice and general well-being, not as a religious prohibition. There is no inherent contradiction between these narrations and the Qur’an, which allows the consumption of livestock. Rather, the guidance may be an example of the Prophet’s concern for his community’s physical health—something that aligns with the holistic objectives of Islamic law (Maqasid al-Shari‘ah).

It is also important to note that these narrations are not specifically about cow meat, as is often misunderstood or debated. The caution pertains to excessive consumption of cattle or bovine (cow and buffalo) meat in general. Although goats also fall under the category of livestock and their meat is considered red meat, they are not included in this caution, likely because goat meat contains less fat compared to cattle.

Lastly, it’s worth mentioning that in India, excessive consumption of red meat is rare. Our meat dishes are typically part of meals that include roti (bread) and curry, and are prepared with a variety of beneficial spices. In contrast, meat consumption in some other cultures often involves larger portions with minimal use of spices, potentially increasing health risks.   

0 Comments

UN: Declare 12 Rabi ul Awwal as 'Global Compassion Day'.


Help us to Declare 12 Rabi ul Awwal as 'Global Compassion Day'.

Petition 1:  https://chng.it/qfwJGZGQvn
Petition 2 : Secure Avaaz

This will close in 0 seconds